This two-minute film, created by 72andSunny, reviews the top searches of 2016 through footage of the moments that tore us apart and pulled us together over the course of the year. After a tumultuous year, marked by moments of intense tragedy and polarization, Google manages to bring us something surprisingly uplifting and hopeful. In testing, viewer response was overwhelmingly positive. By overall score, the film falls in the top one percent of all ads tested this year to date, and it is the third highest scoring out of nearly 700 technology ads tested. The combination of high Breakthrough and Relevance forms an Ad Personality consistent with Google’s 2014 and 2015 versions of “Year in Search.”
No surprise, viewers named the visual scenes (27 percent) and the message (32 percent) the best things about the ad. With highly impressive scores across virtually every demographic segment—age, gender, ethnicity, region, and income—some of the most interesting nuances in the responses are within the emotional resonance by age group. The emotional word cloud below provides a visual representation of words from all viewer comments correlated with specific emotions.
Emotional Word Cloud
It is in the comments of 21 to 35 year olds that we see the greatest amount of emotion evoked by Google’s creative gem. It is also this group that derived the most hope from it.
- “Made me teary-eyed. Showcased how horrible 2016 was but I believe in love so it made me hopeful.” – F21-35/Caucasian
- “Good job Google, this is a great ad. Emotional, hopeful, inspiring, heartwarming. The world is a scary place, but this brightened my day.” – F21-35/Other
- “Very inspirational. Gives me some hope for the future!” – M21-35/Asian
The youngest viewers, 16 to 20 year olds, had the highest percentage of comments that indicated heartfelt emotion. It is also this group that provided the only comment (out if 352 total) referring to anyone shown in the video by name.
- “The Google ‘Year in Review’ ads really are very emotional because you can go back and remember what happens, and even among the bad, there were moments of hope and goodness. I almost cried, because Lin-Manuel Miranda’s Tony acceptance speech really summed up what we needed, and it was a main focus.” – F16-20/Hispanic
- “That was the most touching video I have ever seen. I cried a bit, but I loved that video very much. You just don’t understand how much I loved it.” – M16-20/African American
- “It’s a really thoughtful message to the world, that we have to stand together and unite as one or as whole, not separate ourselves from others.” – M16-20/Caucasian
Though they were the least likely to verbalize how the ad tugged at their heartstrings, 36 to 49 year olds are not completely jaded. Perhaps they’re just a bit more pragmatic.
- “There just might be a common thread that binds all of humanity together and hate can not unravel it.” – M36-49/Caucasian
- “By showing the good and the bad of the year it helps us to reflect that no matter what there is still good out there and we can make a difference if we want to … or try.” – M36-49/Caucasian
- “Such a great spot to help promote what we’re capable of learning if we use the internet properly.” – M36-49/Hispanic
Landing in the lowest 2 percent of Polarity Scores, the ad did not receive much in the way of negative feedback. There are always bound to be naysayers, but in general, Google brought viewers back from the precipice and reminded us that “we are the music makers, and we are the dreamers of dreams.” And for that, I think they deserve our thanks.
See you in 2017!